Denied: Cascadia & Rylet Border Change

As you know the changes in Version 18. Debate, say you don't like it. Won't be surprised much if you do...

I think you should leave a little space for Shayden's borders to reach the coast. I'm fine with the rest as long as you can resolve your .psd issue.

eh, i'm planning on taking the rest of Shayden and i'm good with just the East stuff.

Shayden is still part of a lot of Adonian history. Maybe we should have it as a protected NPC. If not, just change all names in the history to Acadia.

Changes? What changes? Need a map, I do.

eh, i'll take it.

I concur, make Shayden a protected NPC nation. Follvirkeland still technically has strong ties with Shayden.

Unfortunately, I have to side with Shayden being a Protected NPC Nation (it would really mess up Okaiken's history and I probably have the strongest ties to Shayden D:

I don't know why it would be unfortunate. lol Shayden used to be a played nation. It should be left alone.

If the proposal concerns cutting up all or part of Shayden's territory (which it's beginning to sound like after reading the forums), then side me with those who wish Shayden to be a Protected NPC - for the reasons already mentioned above.

I agree with protecting Shayden. But judging by the new locations Nate and Tyler chose, they obviously want some of Shayden's West Coast. Compromise?

Both countries get the West Coast, but Shayden still has some of it, too. Sorry for the bad quality. I used the jpg version, too.

I think Jack's idea will work well we just need a spot on the West for Shayden D:

@Jack - wow that's a good quality

I'm not so sure about Rylet's position in the compromise (plus, Luther/Cascadia is already one of our biggest nations), but otherwise it looks okay, I guess.

Daniel: Here was the original map of the changes they wanted. I just tried to make it a little more realistic.

Okay, if it came down to a choice between your compromise and the original border change - I'm definitely going with the the compromise.

Lol. Where are Nate and Tyler?

Also, I need to make sure the Fraesian Confederacy is protected.

How is it a compromise when we never agreed? Make Rylet Longer along the
Cascadia border right above the U in Euphemia. Than you have yourself a
deal. Im not concerned with letting Shayden have a West Coast. But you
sliced Rylet by 75%. If you're going to take away only take half.
Otherwise I'm not sure how you can say this is a fair deal

Sorry about the confusion, Nate. I called it a compromise because other members were against the changes entirely. The compromise was you two being able to move, but not take up Shayden's entire West Coast.

I will extend it to the U, I didn't know where specifically Tyler wanted to be, I'm sorry you don't like the one I posted.

I'll get on this right away.

DENIED by the Cartographic Committee (Remember, it is headed by Daniel, Kurt and Carl)

Reason: Members in this proposal are permanently banned in the Union.